Canal Water Review

"To teach superstitions as truth is a most terrible thing." Hypatia "Yeah. That pretty much sucks canal water." cwr

Tuesday, September 14, 2004

Surviving

Another Survivor series starts on Thursday night. This is a much anticipated event in our house. It is something of a guilty pleasure for My Prince and me, but we enjoy the series immensely. We have been faithful viewers since the very first series a few years ago, and we always look forward to the new series when it comes out.

A great deal of our interest in the series is because it reflects some of our own experience in living in East Africa. At different points in time, I lived in Kenya and then in Tanzania. My Prince joined me in Tanzania. The experience was life-altering in some critical ways, but most particularly in giving us a greater appreciation of how luxurious is our material wealth in the U.S. Life here, no matter how hard, is really easy compared to what it is in a third world country.

We have always been a bit thrifty. That comes from having parents who lived through the Great Depression and World War II. We were both taught to treat our possessions with care, to think twice before we spent money. After East Africa, we became avid recyclers. We not only recycle, we re-use. Plastic drink bottles can be cut down to form really neat "bins" for sorting all those nuts and bolts that My Prince has been hoarding for a zillion years. Cardboard boxes are dutifully brought home from the office to be used for storing the books that no longer fit on the shelves (I'm saving them for my retirement, when I hope to re-read each one!). One old shampoo bottle has been re-used for several years to hold the watered-down shampoo that is doled out from the large-economy-size-on-sale stuff that is much richer than what is actually needed to get one's hair clean.

It's not that we're inordinately cheap--it's more that we have seen what it is like to do without on a fairly grand scale. We know how to purify our water. We know how to entertain ourselves without television or newspapers. We know how to look at "trash" and see what other use something can be put to.

In Dar es Salaam, when we could get margarine, it came in a tin can. How do you keep the flies out? Get a lid! But where? We actually asked our parents to send us old plastic lids in various sizes from the food containers that they were through with. It worked wonderfully. And now we know that we don't have to buy a special lid for the cat food cans--just use the lid from bean dip. (BTW, margarine is whipped oil. It is white--unless the yellow food coloring is added. It did take some getting used to to put white "butter" on bread, but bread was so hard to get, I guess any color would have done just fine.)

So we enjoy watching Survivor these days just to see how Americans can figure out how to live in an impoverished environment. Sometimes we see some really inept responses to the situation; sometimes we see someone who can make a fairly good go of creative use of the environment.

But Survivor is not actually about survival. It's a test of human relations. A group of strangers is placed in a stressful situation and challenged to be the last one standing. We never tire of looking at how people treat each other in this kind of situation. We do understand that each person is "edited" to present them in a particular kind of way. Some perfectly nice person may have a couple of quirks that are then highlighted in the few minutes of footage presented about them, and you'd never know by watching the show that that's a perfectly nice person. But getting past the individuals, we see the group dynamics. We always wonder how the women can't seem to band together to defeat the men. We see the division caused by age and recognize it for a reflection of something going on in our own life. We see how the presentation of self can differ radically from what one is really thinking and can deceive regarding intentions.

We are always amazed to see how much the group dynamics on Survivor highlights some of the problems in society at large. The fear of the "other" that crops up in racism and other -isms is well reflected in Survivor. As often as not, it's the ethnic folks that get voted out sooner rather than later. Although one black woman and one hispanic woman have won a Survivor series, they seem to be exceptions in surviving group dynamics. An Asian woman who quite validly ate parts of a chicken, I think, that most Americans consider inedible was reflecting her culture--and a wise use of protein in a protein-poor environment--was viewed as "gross," "weird," "scary." A native american who knew a few tricks about overcoming hunger and who also knew how to be alone with himself was accused of cheating and eliminated--quite simply because he didn't fit in to the lazier group culture. Interestingly enough, the gay folks who were "out" in the various series seem to be less of an "other" than the ethnic folks.

And, of course, we enjoy watching Survivor because it's just plain fun to try to figure out who is going to win. We always end up having our favorites. Sometimes My Prince and I agree on a favorite, sometimes not. We watch each week--together or separately (sometimes I work late and catch it at the office)--and then talk about our perceptions. We criticize the bumbling survival activities. We analyze the group dynamics. And then we just have a good time trying to figure out who's deceiving the others, who is getting along well, who might be vulnerable to an elimination vote. We tend to like those who work hard at keeping the camp running. We tend to like the ones who are honorable. We are both fairly disgusted with the bimbos.

Thursday night is "date night" at our house. It's best not to call between 7 and 8, cuz we'll be watching Survivor. I can hardly wait!

7 Comments:

At 9/15/2004 9:28 AM, Blogger Sara said...

I am an Apprentice watcher myself. Never got into the whole Survivor thing. Probably because when it came out, I didn't own a TV nor do I now. The boyfriend has one which has lured me back into stupidity watching. Enjoy tomorrow.

 
At 9/16/2004 1:08 AM, Blogger Carolyn A. Parker said...

Thanks, Sara. We're just about ready for a diversion around here. I get a little overwrought about politics, and My Prince is running the back roads of Texas to take care of his parents. A little mindless fun (which we can pretend has educational elements) is looking really good right now.

I hope we're not disappointed. Right now, Rupert, once a household favorite, is starting to annoy me as much as The Donald does.

 
At 9/16/2004 12:58 PM, Blogger Jack said...

I'm a fan(atic) myself...and yet can't stand other "reality" shows.

 
At 9/26/2004 6:00 PM, Blogger Jack said...

Sarge's days seem numbered...he just hollers too much. The black guy will go first, though. I'm a tad disapointed by the girls...they all seem cast from the sdame sorority girl mold, except the two or three "older" girls.

 
At 9/27/2004 9:07 AM, Blogger Carolyn A. Parker said...

[laughing] Now see, across that great political divide we have something else in common.

I agree with your assessment. I want to like Sarge, but it does worry me that he will forget to take a lower profile when needed. Being a drill sergeant, that's a tough challenge. Chris is getting a fair amount of screen time, so I'm (a) liking him a bit more and (b) already speculating on how far he will make it. But my "favorite" fellow right now is the FBI guy, whose name I haven't yet learned, but whose, uh, demeanor still warms this old girl's heart.

On the women's team, I also share your disappointment with the Bowheads. Knowing that they are recruited by the show's producer just to be bowheads allows me to lower my frustration rate. If the old broads can hang together for a while, the Bowheads will be eliminated as a threat before the merge--and the presence of testosterone gets in the way. I'm liking Scout. I thought she would not make it past the first tribal council, since the old girl is often the first to go while they're still thinking about challenges and strength issues. This season's challenges definitely level the playing field for the women. I am also starting to like Twila and her earthy sense of reality.

What strikes me most about this season is how quickly both tribes have fallen into divisions based on age. It is ever true that young folks think they know it all and want to assert their independence as individuals. The thing is--some of these young folks are old enough to have an actual fully formed brain, at which point they should be able to reason out the need to look at life experience as an asset in playing this game.

Well, enjoy, Jack. I'm thinking this will be an interesting season.

 
At 10/04/2004 4:35 PM, Blogger Jack said...

Yeah, you're right on target about how they are stacking up based on age. If Sarge can keep his pie hole shut, he can go far. I don't know who the FBI guy is, I missed the first half hour of the pilot. I was, obviously, dead wrong about the black guy getting the boot. I was bummed when ?Farm Girl? got the boot week before last, but so happy the snide snarky chick (I'm bad about their names) got tossed last week. Should be fun to see how this plays out.

 
At 10/04/2004 10:47 PM, Blogger Carolyn A. Parker said...

Sarge seems to be on the verge of annoying folks now. It will be interesting to see whether he or Rory (the Black Guy) goes next. One of the younger ones might be sacrificed before either of them, Chris (who seems to be thinking in strategic terms) may think he has a strong enough hand to get rid of Sarge a bit earlier. If he does, he may not be in as good a shape as he thinks, because he will have "betrayed" his alliance.

Sometimes it's better to wait a bit to form alliances rather than rushing to judgement on the basis of superficial "qualities." But, then, I guess there often isn't time for that.

The old girls seem to be pretty wily. I, too, was glad when the Snarky One left. I'm guessing the Silly Goose is next. The lass that you are missing was Dolly, the shepherdess, or as the guys said at the challenge: "The Blond!"

Take care.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home